Facts about Fred

There is not much we know for certain in this case. However, there are basic facts we adhere to in our investigation:


  • Male, 5ft 8in tall
  • Estimated age mid-twenties to late thirties
  • Below average build, small hands, well-kept nails
  • Short, light reddish-brown hair, much shorter than usual in late sixties
  • Very bad teeth for his age, undergone extensive dental treatment
  • Prominent underbite – bottom front teeth overlapped top front (bottom jaw protruded)
  • Unusual upper partial denture by UK standard common at the time
  • Latest dental work likely performed around 6 months before he died, dental records untraceable though
  • Potential torticollis (neck condition causing the head to tilt) – only discovered in 2007
  • Never reported missing in the UK (not missed by a wife, an employer, a family or friends…)
  • Plain cheap golden wedding ring on a “wrong” (right) hand in the UK
  • Naked except mustardy nylon socks (not pink)

    TV documentary

    ATV Today: 30.11.1971: Burton-on-Trent Murder Mystery



    • March 26, 1971 – discovery of a skull by David Nathan
    • March 27, 1971 – full body dug up in presence of a pathologist, police investigation begins
    • Post-mortem performed by Keith Mant from King´s College London
    • Decomposition suggested death 9 – 18 months before discovery
    • Autopsy report:
      • Fingerprints available and intact
      • Red flesh still present in abdomen area
      • Some hair still in place


    • Body found in kneeling, squatting position – body upright
    • Right arm dragged across the body and left arm behind it
    • Wrists loosely tied with the same piece of twine
    • Ankles tied similarly – third twine joins the two
    • Common industrial light-blue polypropylene twine – made in Yorkshire
    • Open coroner verdict = not possible to determine the cause of death BASED ON REMAINS
    • No visible injuries, denture still in place (suggesting no blows to the head)
    • Pathologist suggested “deviant sexual practice” (binding) leading to asphyxiation as probable cause of death – no twine around the neck though
    • Remark of marks on top of his back in the book by Michael Posner
    • Causes of death like smothering, drowning, poisoning, heart attack, stabbing without scratching any bone etc. CANNOT BE EXCLUDED


      • Shallow grave (3ft 7in deep) in light sandy soil
      • Island on river Trent at Winshill (Burton on Trent)
      • At the time land was used by Greensmith’s Mill located on the opposite side of the river (cleaning of a weir)
      • Before 1971 the island was accessible from Winshill by a bridge with a locked gate
      • Access to keys restricted to senior employees of the mill, David Nathan and a farmer
      • Burial site – wooded area, remote location with restricted access = very safe for those with knowledge
      • Unusual shape of the grave most likely easiest to fit the body (rigor mortis or an already existing cavity caused by a flood?)
      • Naked body – either died naked or clothes removed to prevent identification (possibly distinctive clothes, uniform?)
      • Twine might have been used for transportation of the body (“moveable package”)

      The ring and its significance in the timeline

      • 9ct gold wedding band – the plainest possible
      • Found on right-hand wedding ring finger
      • 18mm inside diameter = O1/2 UK ring size
      • Considered a common female size, unusually small for a man – lowest 8% of male hands
      • UK hallmark present = manufactured in England
      • Hallmark date “S” signifies date of manufacturing within last 6 months of 1967 and first 6 months of 1968
      • Time needs to be allowed for manufacturer to sell to retailer and retailer to sell ring – probably minimum 3 months
      • Not sold BEFORE 1968, earliest possible date of sale spring 1969


      Fred the Head

      Do you want to stay up to date on the latest developments in our investigation? Follow our Facebook page and join the discussion. We will regularly host online meetings where we will answer your questions in real time.

      Sometimes, we need an expert’s opinion on a specific matter. Maybe it’s you or someone you know! Join the discussion and become part of the live investigation. 

      Help us solve Fred’s mysterious death. Send us your tips, theories or finds.